Seller Strategy | Lake Nona

How to Price Against New Construction When Selling Your Lake Nona Home

Here is something most sellers do not realize until they are in the middle of a negotiation: buyers are comparing your home to the builder's base price, not to the builder's actual delivered price. That gap can cost you.

Lake Nona has always had active new construction. Builders like David Weekley, Ashton Woods, Taylor Morrison, Minto, and others are consistently delivering new homes across Laureate Park, Storey Park, and surrounding communities. And every one of those builders has a marketing machine showing buyers photos of model homes and advertising a base price that makes their product look like an unbeatable deal.

If you are selling a resale home in Lake Nona right now, you need to understand how to price against that narrative strategically. Not by racing to the bottom on price, but by helping buyers see the full picture.

The Builder Base Price Problem

Here is how the builder pricing game works.

A builder advertises a 4-bedroom home starting at $519,900. Buyers drive the model, fall in love with the upgraded kitchen, the luxury vinyl plank floors, the extended covered lanai, and the quartz countertops throughout. What they do not always read carefully is that those features are not in the base price. They are options. And by the time a buyer selects the finishes they actually want, that home is often $80,000 to $150,000 above the advertised base.

Add builder lot premiums, structural options like additional bedrooms or bonus rooms, and the extended closing timeline, and the calculation shifts considerably.

Your resale home already has all of that. The question is whether your pricing reflects it.

Five Pricing Strategies That Work Against Builders

1. Price Against the Fully-Loaded New Construction Cost, Not the BaseWork with your agent to identify what a comparable new construction home actually costs after options. That is your real competition number. If the equivalent new home is $690,000 all-in, pricing your resale at $659,000 to $669,000 positions you as the better value, not the cheaper option.
2. Quantify Your Installed ValueMake a list of everything that is already in your home that buyers would pay extra for in a builder model: upgraded flooring, extended patio, fencing, gutters, landscape lighting, plantation shutters, storage solutions, and more. These are real dollars. Document them and show buyers the math. Many sellers undersell their own homes because they forget what they paid for upgrades that now blend in so naturally.
3. Price the Time ValueAn 8 to 14 month build timeline is not free. For buyers with a job starting in 60 days, a school enrollment deadline, or a lease expiring, your 30 to 45 day closing is worth a real premium. Your agent should be asking buyers' agents about timeline sensitivity and positioning accordingly.
4. Highlight the Mature Community AdvantageNew construction phases often mean construction noise, incomplete amenities, and a neighborhood that looks like a job site for months. Your resale home sits in an established section of the community with mature trees, a completed streetscape, and neighbors who are not moving in from a waiting list. That has value to buyers who have done the new construction experience before.
5. Understand the Builder Incentive SeasonBuilders run aggressive incentive programs at quarter-end and at year-end to hit their absorption goals. If you are listing during one of those windows, expect buyers to use builder incentives as leverage. Your agent should track builder incentive activity as part of your pricing strategy. For a deeper look at this dynamic, see our article on how to compete with builder incentives in Lake Nona.

What Resale Homes Win on Every Time

Advantage	Resale Home	New Construction
Closing timeline	30 to 45 days typical	8 to 14 months typical
Landscaping	Established, mature	Sod only at closing
Fencing	Often included	Extra option, added cost
Window treatments	Typically installed	Bare windows at closing
Gutters	Usually present	Often an added option
Neighborhood activity	Established, stable	Active construction nearby
Price transparency	What you see is what you pay	Base price plus options plus lot

The Overpricing Trap

Some sellers overcorrect and price too high, assuming their resale upgrades justify a premium well above the builder's delivered price. That is also a losing strategy.

Buyers can see the builder's price sheet. If your home is priced above what an equivalent new construction home costs, buyers will choose the new home even if the timeline is longer, because they are getting exactly what they want and brand new warranty coverage on top of it.

The sweet spot is being priced at or slightly below the true delivered cost of a comparable new construction home. For more on why pricing discipline matters, read our article on why overpricing your Lake Nona home costs you money.

And for the full pricing framework before you list, the Lake Nona home pricing guide for 2026 walks through how to build a price strategy using real market data.

The Right Conversation to Have With Your Agent

Before you price your Lake Nona home, ask your agent these questions:

• What is the true delivered price of a comparable new construction home in this neighborhood right now, including lot premium and popular options?
• What features in my home represent installed value that buyers would pay for as options in a builder model?
• Is the builder running any incentive promotions this quarter that might pull buyers away during our listing period?
• What is the builder's current inventory of available and move-in-ready homes nearby?

The answers to those questions shape your pricing strategy. A good agent in Lake Nona is watching builder activity as closely as resale activity because both sides set the market.

---

Frequently Asked Questions

How do I compete with new construction pricing in Lake Nona?

Price against the builder's fully-loaded delivered cost, not the advertised base price. Most buyers find that a builder home with their desired features costs $80,000 to $150,000 more than the base. Your resale home, priced at or below that true cost, wins on value plus instant occupancy.

Should I lower my price to compete with builders?

Not automatically. Lower your price only if data shows your home is overpriced relative to what buyers can get new. If your home represents genuine value at its current price, the work is in presentation and communication, not just discounting.

What are Lake Nona build timelines right now?

Builders in Lake Nona are typically quoting 8 to 14 months from contract to closing. Resale homes typically close in 30 to 45 days. For buyers with timeline constraints, resale wins on that factor alone.